How to brief a presentation designer (draw the ugly box)
A brief arrived recently that I want to describe, because it’s becoming common and it’s costing people money.
One slide of a deck was a single large rectangle. Inside the rectangle was a paragraph, clearly generated, explaining how the slide should be designed. Three boxes across the top with this content in each. A chart below, showing this. A callout to the right saying that. Two hundred words of layout described in prose.
It took me longer to decode that paragraph than it would have taken to design the slide. A rough sketch, three lumpy rectangles and a squiggle for the chart, would have told me the same thing in four seconds. The briefer could have drawn it in a minute. Instead they asked a tool to write it, the tool wrote something thorough, and the thoroughness became my problem, billed by the hour.
Prose is a terrible way to describe a picture. That’s the whole post, really, but let me make it useful.
What a good brief actually contains
After sixteen years of receiving them, the briefs that produce the best decks fastest share five things. None of them require design skill.
The purpose, in one sentence. Who’s in the room, what should be true when the deck ends. “Convince the board to fund phase two” beats any description of slides, because it lets me make a thousand small decisions you’d never think to specify.
The content, in whatever state it’s in. The Word doc, the spreadsheet, the old deck, the email chain. Raw is fine. Raw is better than pre-formatted, because pre-formatting is decisions made without the information I’ll have later.
The ugly sketch. For any slide where you have a picture in your head, draw it. Pen, paper, phone photo. Boxes, arrows, a scribble where the chart goes. It doesn’t matter how bad it looks. A bad drawing communicates a layout faster than any words, and it tells me what you’re picturing so I can either build it or tell you why something else would work better.
What’s fixed and what’s open. “The three pillars must stay in this order” is useful. “Make it look good” is a blank cheque you’ll pay for. Tell me what can’t change and I’ll spend the creative effort where it’s welcome.
The date, honestly. Not the date you’d like. The one it’s actually needed for, and who has to sign it off before then.
What wastes money
Describing layouts in words. See above. If you can picture it, draw it. If you can’t picture it, don’t describe it, tell me what it needs to achieve and let me picture it.
Formatting before briefing. Hours spent making a rough deck look tidy are hours I’ll undo, because tidy-but-wrong takes longer to fix than rough-and-clear.
Briefing slide by slide when the problem is the story. If the argument doesn’t work, no amount of slide-level instruction saves it. Brief the deck first, the slides second.
Generated briefs. The tools are good at producing complete-sounding documents, which is exactly the wrong quality in a brief. A brief should be short, opinionated and full of gaps that a conversation fills. A generated one is long, neutral and full of confident detail that nobody actually decided. I can’t tell which sentences you meant.
The AI version of all this
I use AI tools daily and I’m not telling you not to. Use them to summarise the source material, to draft the slide copy, to tighten your argument. Those are real hours saved.
Just don’t use them to describe the picture. The moment you’re generating a paragraph about where boxes should go, stop, and draw the boxes. The gap between your sketch and my slide is the whole reason you hired a designer. The paragraph doesn’t close it. It just makes it harder to see. And if the deck itself came out of one of these tools looking like it needs help, that’s a related problem with its own fix.
The short version
Tell me what the meeting’s for. Give me the content raw. Draw the ugly box. Say what’s fixed. Give me the real date.
Do that and the brief takes you fifteen minutes, the deck comes back right first time, and you spend less, because clarity is cheaper than thoroughness every single time.
If you’re working out whether that brief goes to a freelancer, an agency or a platform, I’ve written about the difference. And if you want the number before we talk, the pricing is published.
Dan Plumb is a presentation designer with sixteen years of agency-grade work, formerly Global Head of Design at Publicis Media, working with clients directly at depicts.com.
Got something important coming up?
I’m Dan Plumb. Sixteen years designing agency-grade presentations for the world’s most recognised brands. Let’s talk about yours.